Runner-up PGR Prize at RGS-IBG 2025: Lotte Luykx

At this year’s RGS-IBG Annual International Conference, Lotte Luykx, a doctoral researcher at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel, was one of the two runner-ups for the PGR Prize for Best Postgraduate Presentation.

We are delighted to share a short blog post by Lotte, based on their award-winning presentation: How can we build consensus on the transformation of streets into sustainable and people-centred oases?

Streets are more than passageways for cars, they are the largest public spaces in our cities. Transforming streets into places for people is key to creating sustainable urban environments. But change rarely comes without friction as a new street layout or circulation plan affects people’s everyday mobility, behaviours, and habits.

In Brussels, for example, a plan to reduce traffic in several neighbourhoods was met with heavy protests. Citizens dismantled installations, interrupted council meetings, and eventually, the execution of the plan was put to a halt. Similarly, in Oxford, UK, the Central Oxfordshire Travel Plan faced opposition. These examples show that even well-intentioned plans that integrate participatory principles can become points of conflict.

While resources exist to aid design and implementation, a lack of evidence remains on how to support decision-making among diverse stakeholder groups. Furthermore, evaluating the effectiveness of participatory tools is challenging, since it involves navigating a variety of formats and complexities in stakeholder engagement.

This leads to a major challenge in the sustainable transition of cities: how can local communities make street transformations that work for everyone?

New approaches to participation: the Streetforum project

The StreetForum project, coordinated by Vrije Universiteit Brussel, addresses this question and investigates how to support local communities in building consensus among inhabitants, businesses, public services, local organisations, municipalities, and other groups. The project’s aim is not only to reach agreements but to create a meaningful process that welcomes diverging opinions and builds a common understanding.

Building on the expertise of the project partners, including universities, municipalities, NGOs, and businesses, the international StreetForum consortium has developed a toolkit of nine creative and bottom-up methods to engage people in new ways:

  • Narrative-based tools: storytelling workshops, art interviews, and visual rich pictures
  • Playful tools: co-design games, collaborative installations, and public living rooms
  • Digital tools: a crowdsourcing platform and street-assessment tool, with hybrid applications that allow broader participation

A novel evaluation framework for consensus-building

To assess the impact of the different tools on consensus-building, we developed a novel evaluation framework, building on a model by Innes and Booher (1999). This includes indicators like the creation of a common understanding, building trust, empowerment, awareness-raising, and process and outcome quality. A difficulty in assessing these innovative tools is their variety. Therefore, the tools were grouped into three categories: workshop-like tools, digital applications, and on-street activities.

Testing the Toolkit in Living Labs

The project set up Living Labs in four cities (Brussels, Istanbul, Stockholm, and Vienna) through participatory trajectories in collaboration with citizens, NGOs, local authorities, and businesses. Each tool was demonstrated and tested in at least two out of the four locations. The evaluation resulted in 230 surveys from participants and 68 from facilitators and structured observations.

What makes a participatory tool impactful?

The findings revealed a nuanced picture. While none of the tools scored high on all indicators, combining formats can significantly improve outcomes. The evaluation showed that:

  • Playful tools and gamification can be impactful, but need to be combined with active listening and agency over game rules
  • On-street activities help build trust and encourage reflection on the use of a street, but need to be combined with facilitated discussion on the issues
  • Digital tools can increase the number of participants, but need to be used in a hybrid format to ensure inclusivity

In the end, the living labs resulted mostly in non-conclusive outcomes. Agreements focused on how the street should be used, proposals for activities organised by citizens and local governments, and small or temporary interventions to improve the street.

Challenges for inclusivity

Inclusivity remains a challenge in many participatory processes. Innovative tools may help engage hard-to-reach groups. While our activities did not sufficiently reach certain stakeholders, like car users and elderly people, or children, a diversity of formats did increase diversity among participants. Key learnings are that:

  • Building trust is fostered through recurring on-street activities and working with local organisations
  • Visual elements can help bridge language barriers
  • Accessible digital tools can reach stakeholders with time constraints like shop owners

Future research

The impact assessment showed that combining different formats and tools is essential for inclusive and impactful decision-making around street transformations. By lowering the threshold for participation, the toolkit brings a more diverse group of people around the table.

The evaluation did come with its limitations. Children and young people were not included in the evaluation, and our sample underrepresented car users and older people. Certain indicators, like trust or clarity of the goal, may depend on external factors such as the local political situation. Future research should further involve decision-makers in participatory research and explore how to scale up or embed the tools in policy.

In the next phase of my PhD, I will focus on how these emerging and creative participatory methods can be adapted to better include children in mobility issues. Children’s voices are often missing from urban and mobility planning, yet they are strongly affected by the design of streets and cities.

Lotte Luykx, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Mobilise Research Group, part of the House of Sustainable Transitions.

StreetForum is a JPI Urban Europe project. The research and activities in Belgium are supported by Innoviris.

Best Undergraduate Dissertation Award: Toby Piper, University of Manchester

This year, Toby Piper, an undergraduate student at the University of Manchester, won the award for the Best Undergraduate Dissertation. We are delighted to share a short blog post by Toby, based on their award-winning work:

‘Going Nowhere fast: Transport Inequality, Civic Exclusion, and Youth Loneliness in Rural Wiltshire.

My project, Going Nowhere Fast: Transport Inequality, Civic Exclusion, and Youth Loneliness in Rural Wiltshire, grew out of both personal experience and academic inquiry. At its heart, it explores how mobility – or the lack of – shapes young people’s opportunities, sense of belonging, and well-being in rural environments.

Growing up in Poulshot, an isolated village southwest of Devizes, Wiltshire, I became acutely aware of the constraints of rural mobility. Attending after-school activities or simply meeting friends in town was rarely straightforward. Without safe cycling infrastructure or reliable buses, social life often depended on lifts from parents or friends. This lack of autonomy left many of us feeling cut off. More than just a personal frustration, it raised bigger questions about how infrastructure – or its absence – quietly shapes social inclusion, health, and life chances for rural youth. These lived experiences gave direction to my dissertation and connected with wider debates about loneliness and well-being, which research shows are particularly acute among young people and can have significant psychological and physiological effects. From this starting point, I set out to explore how transport systems — and the governance structures behind them — contribute to loneliness and exclusion in rural Wiltshire.

Academically, the study engages with concepts of spatial, mobility, and transport justice. Scholars such as Tim Cresswell and Mimi Sheller argue that mobility is not just about movement, but about access and the power relations that shape it. In rural areas, this becomes evident in what Shucksmith calls ‘place-based disadvantage,’ where limited transport and connectivity reinforce the structural neglect of peripheral communities in planning and investment. Much of the literature on transport and justice is urban-focused, yet rural youth face unique forms of exclusion. By bringing a rural, youth-centred perspective into these debates, my dissertation aimed to address this gap and foreground voices too often overlooked in both scholarship and policy.

To investigate these dynamics, I adopted a qualitative methodology. Three semi-structured interviews with members of Wiltshire Council were combined with a desk review of policy documents, like Wiltshire’s Local Transport Plan, and a wider literature review. This triangulated approach allowed me to situate the perspectives of practitioners within broader institutional and academic contexts, while grounding findings in real-world policy frameworks. The research focused on Devizes, a relatively well-connected market town, and three surrounding villages – Poulshot, Urchfont, and Worton. Comparing these locations highlighted stark differences in transport infrastructure and accessibility and helped illustrate the uneven geography of youth inclusion in central Wiltshire.

The results were striking. While Devizes enjoys frequent bus services, clear timetables, and decent pedestrian infrastructure, the neighbouring villages contend with infrequent transport—sometimes as few as two buses a day—unreliable schedules, hazardous cycling conditions, and bus stops that are either poorly maintained or missing altogether. For many young people, this means social opportunities end when the last bus leaves in the afternoon. Such infrastructural shortcomings only serve to deepen feelings of exclusion. 

Yet the research also pointed to tangible interventions. Expanding demand-responsive transport: flexible, app-based bus services that could provide viable alternatives in low-density areas. Improving infrastructure for active travel through well-lit footways, safe crossings, and bus stops with shelters and timetables could dramatically enhance accessibility. Decentralised, youth-led governance could empower parish councils to fund micro-projects — from safe paths to upgraded bus stops — while youth co-design panels could embed young voices into decision-making processes. Bridging the digital divide is also crucial: digital tools like Bustimes.org hold potential, but patchy broadband and poor awareness undermine their impact. Combining improved connectivity with physical timetables and youth-oriented outreach could help. These recommendations stress that mobility is not only about infrastructure but also about governance, participation, and inclusion.

Ultimately, the dissertation demonstrates how transport justice intersects with youth well-being. Limited mobility is not just an inconvenience; it undermines autonomy, restricts opportunities, and exacerbates loneliness. By situating these experiences within frameworks of spatial and mobility justice, the study highlights how infrastructural invisibility in rural areas perpetuates cycles of exclusion. For policymakers, the message is clear: equitable investment in rural transport and youth participation is not optional but essential. For academics, the case reinforces the need to broaden mobility research beyond urban contexts, recognising how rural youth navigate a distinctive set of challenges shaped by both geography and governance.

Winning the TGRG prize was an unexpected but deeply affirming moment. More importantly, I hope the research contributes to ongoing conversations about how we design transport systems and civic spaces that work for everyone, not just those in urban centres. The journey that began with long waits at village bus stops and risky cycles into town has, in a sense, come full circle. By connecting personal experience with academic theory and policy analysis, this dissertation aimed to show that rural youth exclusion is neither inevitable nor invisible. With targeted interventions and a commitment to justice, it can be addressed — creating rural futures where young people feel connected, included, and able to move through space on their own terms.

Toby Piper, University of Manchester

Runner-up PGR Prize at RGS-IBG 2025: Vanessa Ternes

At this year’s RGS-IBG Annual International Conference, Vanessa Ternes, a doctoral researcher at the University of Leeds, was one of the two runner-ups for the PGR Prize for Best Postgraduate Presentation.

We are delighted to share a short blog post by Vanessa, based on their award-winning presentation: Making participants feel valued: The role of facilitation skills in participatory research.

Workshops, focus groups and other participatory methods are commonly used in geography research. In my latest work, where I studied the perceptions of the public towards the Zero Emission Vehicle mandate, I conducted several workshops with members of the public. When preparing for them, I found plenty of guidance on WHAT to do: Which methods to use, how to structure a workshop, different ways to elicit information, capture input and seek feedback from participants.

But HOW do we do this? How do you conduct yourself as a facilitator, how to you make participants feel safe and welcome, how do you react to every group and every individual with the same level of interest, curiosity and warmth? After all, how we conduct ourselves as facilitators matters for how willing a participant will be to share their views and speak up. Already in 1954, Hyman et al. (in Seale et al. 2004) noted that interviews benefit from having a good rapport with interviewees, and from consistently applying the procedures and methods to increase homogeneity across the interviews. I like to illustrate this with the following comparison: If you were to do a lab experiment, you’d make sure that your equipment is clean and calibrated to get consistent measurements.

In a research workshop, we researchers are effectively the lab experiment, bringing out and capturing insights from our participants. However, as humans we are not known for our consistency. We may feel energetic one day and tired the next. And, as Ralph and Delbosc (2017) have shown, also transport experts are not free of bias. This risks that we react more enthusiastically to a participant who’s views we share than to one bringing in a different perspective. All of this has potential to influence participant reactions and thereby research outcomes.

To mitigate this risk, I sought facilitation training. It was surprisingly hard to find training on the soft skills needed for participatory research, and I hope to see more work on this in the future. In the meantime, I am sharing two game-changing approaches to facilitation that helped my research.

First and foremost, with the facilitation coach I developed a scenario-based plan for the workshops. This plan covered a range of possible social situations and contained structured approaches for how to handle these situations. For example, what do you do when a participant interrupts you? How do you go about it when two participants have different views?

To give a tangible example: How do you react when a participant drifts into a long monologue? In my research project, the workshop conversations were captured in a mindmap that I drew in real time with the participants. I thus decided that I’d interrupt a monologue as soon as I’d lose sight of how to capture the contribution in the mindmap. Having a few sentences prepared was helpful, such as “Let me briefly interrupt you. I really want to capture your thoughts in the mindmap, could you give me one short sentence to write down?”. Making a participant feel valued also when I interrupted was important to me here.

Secondly, at the start of each workshop I introduced a set of group rules. These included points like “Every contribution is valuable. If we agree with someone, we let them finish their thoughts and then share our own.” and “We will ensure the workshop ends on time.”. These intentions were shared and agreed on at the start of the workshop, with participants having a chance to comment. Through the workshop, the group rules could be used to legitimate facilitator interventions. For example, an existing commitment to keep the workshop to time can be referred back to as a reason to interrupt a monologue.

I didn’t specifically seek to measure the effects of the facilitation training, as at the time I didn’t anticipate just how much of a difference they made. Yet the results were positive. Being prepared and able to facilitate all ten workshops in a consistent and participant-focused manner helped to get a consistent depth of conversation across the groups. Participants commented on enjoying the conversations and felt happy about their contributions and the work of the group. While participants had the option to share anonymous thoughts in writing, none of them did – an indicator that everyone felt safe to speak and share their views to the group.

In the future, I hope to see more conversations around facilitation and the soft skills required for research with participants. I encourage every researcher to think about their own strengths and weaknesses around facilitation, and to prepare for the scenarios and social situations they expect to encounter in their research.

My thanks go to the TGRG for organising several sessions on Creative Methods at the recent RGS conference in Birmingham. Having the space to reflect on and discuss how we do research allows us all to learn from each other – thank you to everyone taking part in these conversations!

Vanessa Ternes, Institute for Transport Studies, University of Leeds

PGR Prize at RGS-IBG 2025: Yi Fan Liu

At this year’s RGS-IBG Annual International Conference, Yi Fan Liu, a doctoral researcher at the University of Oxford, won the PGR Prize for Best Postgraduate Presentation.

We are delighted to share a short blog post by Yi Fan, based on their award-winning presentation: Why does gender matter in car-sharing services?

This was a question that I sought to answer with one of my doctoral research papers at the recent RGS Annual International Conference 2025. Car-sharing services are not new; they have emerged since the late 1940s in European cities like Zurich (‘Sefage’, a car-sharing service that started in 1948), Montpellier (‘Procotip’ in 1971) and Amsterdam (‘Witkar’ in 1973). These initiatives were motivated by the idea that people could still access a car without having to shoulder the costs of private car ownership, and services that mobilised electric car fleets had the added benefit of reducing pollution on the road.

Since then, car-sharing services have also expanded rapidly across North American and Asian cities, capturing the attention of various stakeholders and groups that view car-sharing services as potential alternatives to car dependency, while facilitating car-based mobilities for those who need them. App-based car-sharing services populate much of our urban spaces for the past two decades, with some of the major players like Zipcar still operating today.

Yet, the car-sharing scene appears to be slowing down, as numerous companies scale back their operations or shut down completely. While the reasons behind this trend may be myriad, my research on an electric car-sharing service in Singapore, BlueSG, reveals that it is often difficult for the affective experience of a shared car to ultimately outcompete that of a privately owned car.

BlueSG is a free-floating, station-based service that runs on a pay-per-minute basis, and it was established in 2017 by Bolloré, a French transportation and logistics conglomerate that also had similar services running in Paris (Autolib’), London (BlueCity), Los Angeles (BlueLA) and Indianapolis (BlueIndy). For this paper in particular, I attempted to understand what car-sharing experiences were like for users. I interviewed 17 BlueSG users, after which I rode along with them for one car-sharing trip that was entirely determined by them in terms of purpose, duration and location.

The majority of my participants were Singaporean Chinese men in their 20s to 40s. Whilst their sexualities were not shared, many of them had direct references to ‘girlfriends’ and ‘wives’. For them, they saw a car as a means of performing one’s breadwinning sensibilities in heteronormative relationships, and there was a shared sense of unease that the shared car instead felt ‘plasticky’, ‘cheap’, ‘unromantic’ and so on. The pay-per-minute shared cars were not always in the best physical or aesthetic condition, as users – including some of those who participated in my study – would drive as quickly as they can to minimise their costs of using the service. Further, for a free-floating fleet, maintenance of the vehicles can be difficult to keep up with.

Many of the car-sharing users in my study also juxtaposed their experiences against ‘other men on the road’ who seemed to drive their own cars. Driving a shared car from a standardised fleet often felt out of place amidst the sea of privately owned cars, and this affective experience is further intensified in the context of Singapore, where car ownership is made costly through the Certificate of Entitlement and is therefore seen as a point of aspiration for many Singaporeans. Unsurprisingly, many of my research participants still retained the desire to own a car if they can eventually afford it in the future.

A line-up of BlueSG shared electric cars in a car park. Source: Author

So why does gender matter in car-sharing services? It matters because a shared car is not just a car, but it also invokes expectations amongst users which are often gendered in nature. Looking at the historical context of automobility, cars and private car ownership have frequently been tied to mobility, freedom and status for men of certain class, race and sexuality (Daggett, 2018). Automobility has also helmed significant aesthetic power in our urban environment through decades of marketing, engineering and consumption (Gartman, 2004), all of which produce particular car cultures that cannot be disentangled from existing gendered politics. While car cultures have certainly evolved over time and the socio-cultural meanings of a car have shifted for different groups of people, my research finds that there remains an underlying sense that a (shared) car still matters in the way people see themselves in relation to others. In the case of a car-sharing service that has a majority male user base, gendered expectations arising from the wider automobile landscape are often woven into one’s subjective experiences of car-sharing.

What are the implications of my research? It is important to reiterate that car-sharing services are still necessary in meeting the practical needs of people who need a car, and they serve a great purpose in cities that may not yet have strong public transportation systems or infrastructures for active mobility. However, if we are seeking to move away from private automobility, then we might need to ask if the car-sharing services that we have today are compelling enough alternatives to compete with the deeply embedded affective economies of automobility. This may require having nuanced understandings of what people expect in a car, not just in terms of its utility or functionality, but also in terms of its materiality, semiotic expression and socio-cultural meaning. Crucially, in thinking about the wider economies of car-sharing services, specifically the ways in which they operationalise on lean, platform-based business models, there may be a need to recalibrate the kinds of organisational structures that would be robust enough to provide a car-sharing experience that is as good as, if not better than, a privately owned car.

Yi Fan Liu, Transport Studies Unit, University of Oxford