Best Undergraduate Dissertation Award: Toby Piper, University of Manchester

This year, Toby Piper, an undergraduate student at the University of Manchester, won the award for the Best Undergraduate Dissertation. We are delighted to share a short blog post by Toby, based on their award-winning work:

‘Going Nowhere fast: Transport Inequality, Civic Exclusion, and Youth Loneliness in Rural Wiltshire.

My project, Going Nowhere Fast: Transport Inequality, Civic Exclusion, and Youth Loneliness in Rural Wiltshire, grew out of both personal experience and academic inquiry. At its heart, it explores how mobility – or the lack of – shapes young people’s opportunities, sense of belonging, and well-being in rural environments.

Growing up in Poulshot, an isolated village southwest of Devizes, Wiltshire, I became acutely aware of the constraints of rural mobility. Attending after-school activities or simply meeting friends in town was rarely straightforward. Without safe cycling infrastructure or reliable buses, social life often depended on lifts from parents or friends. This lack of autonomy left many of us feeling cut off. More than just a personal frustration, it raised bigger questions about how infrastructure – or its absence – quietly shapes social inclusion, health, and life chances for rural youth. These lived experiences gave direction to my dissertation and connected with wider debates about loneliness and well-being, which research shows are particularly acute among young people and can have significant psychological and physiological effects. From this starting point, I set out to explore how transport systems — and the governance structures behind them — contribute to loneliness and exclusion in rural Wiltshire.

Academically, the study engages with concepts of spatial, mobility, and transport justice. Scholars such as Tim Cresswell and Mimi Sheller argue that mobility is not just about movement, but about access and the power relations that shape it. In rural areas, this becomes evident in what Shucksmith calls ‘place-based disadvantage,’ where limited transport and connectivity reinforce the structural neglect of peripheral communities in planning and investment. Much of the literature on transport and justice is urban-focused, yet rural youth face unique forms of exclusion. By bringing a rural, youth-centred perspective into these debates, my dissertation aimed to address this gap and foreground voices too often overlooked in both scholarship and policy.

To investigate these dynamics, I adopted a qualitative methodology. Three semi-structured interviews with members of Wiltshire Council were combined with a desk review of policy documents, like Wiltshire’s Local Transport Plan, and a wider literature review. This triangulated approach allowed me to situate the perspectives of practitioners within broader institutional and academic contexts, while grounding findings in real-world policy frameworks. The research focused on Devizes, a relatively well-connected market town, and three surrounding villages – Poulshot, Urchfont, and Worton. Comparing these locations highlighted stark differences in transport infrastructure and accessibility and helped illustrate the uneven geography of youth inclusion in central Wiltshire.

The results were striking. While Devizes enjoys frequent bus services, clear timetables, and decent pedestrian infrastructure, the neighbouring villages contend with infrequent transport—sometimes as few as two buses a day—unreliable schedules, hazardous cycling conditions, and bus stops that are either poorly maintained or missing altogether. For many young people, this means social opportunities end when the last bus leaves in the afternoon. Such infrastructural shortcomings only serve to deepen feelings of exclusion. 

Yet the research also pointed to tangible interventions. Expanding demand-responsive transport: flexible, app-based bus services that could provide viable alternatives in low-density areas. Improving infrastructure for active travel through well-lit footways, safe crossings, and bus stops with shelters and timetables could dramatically enhance accessibility. Decentralised, youth-led governance could empower parish councils to fund micro-projects — from safe paths to upgraded bus stops — while youth co-design panels could embed young voices into decision-making processes. Bridging the digital divide is also crucial: digital tools like Bustimes.org hold potential, but patchy broadband and poor awareness undermine their impact. Combining improved connectivity with physical timetables and youth-oriented outreach could help. These recommendations stress that mobility is not only about infrastructure but also about governance, participation, and inclusion.

Ultimately, the dissertation demonstrates how transport justice intersects with youth well-being. Limited mobility is not just an inconvenience; it undermines autonomy, restricts opportunities, and exacerbates loneliness. By situating these experiences within frameworks of spatial and mobility justice, the study highlights how infrastructural invisibility in rural areas perpetuates cycles of exclusion. For policymakers, the message is clear: equitable investment in rural transport and youth participation is not optional but essential. For academics, the case reinforces the need to broaden mobility research beyond urban contexts, recognising how rural youth navigate a distinctive set of challenges shaped by both geography and governance.

Winning the TGRG prize was an unexpected but deeply affirming moment. More importantly, I hope the research contributes to ongoing conversations about how we design transport systems and civic spaces that work for everyone, not just those in urban centres. The journey that began with long waits at village bus stops and risky cycles into town has, in a sense, come full circle. By connecting personal experience with academic theory and policy analysis, this dissertation aimed to show that rural youth exclusion is neither inevitable nor invisible. With targeted interventions and a commitment to justice, it can be addressed — creating rural futures where young people feel connected, included, and able to move through space on their own terms.

Toby Piper, University of Manchester