At this year’s RGS-IBG Annual International Conference, Yi Fan Liu, a doctoral researcher at the University of Oxford, won the PGR Prize for Best Postgraduate Presentation.
We are delighted to share a short blog post by Yi Fan, based on their award-winning presentation: Why does gender matter in car-sharing services?
This was a question that I sought to answer with one of my doctoral research papers at the recent RGS Annual International Conference 2025. Car-sharing services are not new; they have emerged since the late 1940s in European cities like Zurich (‘Sefage’, a car-sharing service that started in 1948), Montpellier (‘Procotip’ in 1971) and Amsterdam (‘Witkar’ in 1973). These initiatives were motivated by the idea that people could still access a car without having to shoulder the costs of private car ownership, and services that mobilised electric car fleets had the added benefit of reducing pollution on the road.
Since then, car-sharing services have also expanded rapidly across North American and Asian cities, capturing the attention of various stakeholders and groups that view car-sharing services as potential alternatives to car dependency, while facilitating car-based mobilities for those who need them. App-based car-sharing services populate much of our urban spaces for the past two decades, with some of the major players like Zipcar still operating today.
Yet, the car-sharing scene appears to be slowing down, as numerous companies scale back their operations or shut down completely. While the reasons behind this trend may be myriad, my research on an electric car-sharing service in Singapore, BlueSG, reveals that it is often difficult for the affective experience of a shared car to ultimately outcompete that of a privately owned car.
BlueSG is a free-floating, station-based service that runs on a pay-per-minute basis, and it was established in 2017 by Bolloré, a French transportation and logistics conglomerate that also had similar services running in Paris (Autolib’), London (BlueCity), Los Angeles (BlueLA) and Indianapolis (BlueIndy). For this paper in particular, I attempted to understand what car-sharing experiences were like for users. I interviewed 17 BlueSG users, after which I rode along with them for one car-sharing trip that was entirely determined by them in terms of purpose, duration and location.
The majority of my participants were Singaporean Chinese men in their 20s to 40s. Whilst their sexualities were not shared, many of them had direct references to ‘girlfriends’ and ‘wives’. For them, they saw a car as a means of performing one’s breadwinning sensibilities in heteronormative relationships, and there was a shared sense of unease that the shared car instead felt ‘plasticky’, ‘cheap’, ‘unromantic’ and so on. The pay-per-minute shared cars were not always in the best physical or aesthetic condition, as users – including some of those who participated in my study – would drive as quickly as they can to minimise their costs of using the service. Further, for a free-floating fleet, maintenance of the vehicles can be difficult to keep up with.
Many of the car-sharing users in my study also juxtaposed their experiences against ‘other men on the road’ who seemed to drive their own cars. Driving a shared car from a standardised fleet often felt out of place amidst the sea of privately owned cars, and this affective experience is further intensified in the context of Singapore, where car ownership is made costly through the Certificate of Entitlement and is therefore seen as a point of aspiration for many Singaporeans. Unsurprisingly, many of my research participants still retained the desire to own a car if they can eventually afford it in the future.

A line-up of BlueSG shared electric cars in a car park. Source: Author
So why does gender matter in car-sharing services? It matters because a shared car is not just a car, but it also invokes expectations amongst users which are often gendered in nature. Looking at the historical context of automobility, cars and private car ownership have frequently been tied to mobility, freedom and status for men of certain class, race and sexuality (Daggett, 2018). Automobility has also helmed significant aesthetic power in our urban environment through decades of marketing, engineering and consumption (Gartman, 2004), all of which produce particular car cultures that cannot be disentangled from existing gendered politics. While car cultures have certainly evolved over time and the socio-cultural meanings of a car have shifted for different groups of people, my research finds that there remains an underlying sense that a (shared) car still matters in the way people see themselves in relation to others. In the case of a car-sharing service that has a majority male user base, gendered expectations arising from the wider automobile landscape are often woven into one’s subjective experiences of car-sharing.
What are the implications of my research? It is important to reiterate that car-sharing services are still necessary in meeting the practical needs of people who need a car, and they serve a great purpose in cities that may not yet have strong public transportation systems or infrastructures for active mobility. However, if we are seeking to move away from private automobility, then we might need to ask if the car-sharing services that we have today are compelling enough alternatives to compete with the deeply embedded affective economies of automobility. This may require having nuanced understandings of what people expect in a car, not just in terms of its utility or functionality, but also in terms of its materiality, semiotic expression and socio-cultural meaning. Crucially, in thinking about the wider economies of car-sharing services, specifically the ways in which they operationalise on lean, platform-based business models, there may be a need to recalibrate the kinds of organisational structures that would be robust enough to provide a car-sharing experience that is as good as, if not better than, a privately owned car.
Yi Fan Liu, Transport Studies Unit, University of Oxford