At this year’s RGS-IBG Annual International Conference, Vanessa Ternes, a doctoral researcher at the University of Leeds, was one of the two runner-ups for the PGR Prize for Best Postgraduate Presentation.
We are delighted to share a short blog post by Vanessa, based on their award-winning presentation: Making participants feel valued: The role of facilitation skills in participatory research.
Workshops, focus groups and other participatory methods are commonly used in geography research. In my latest work, where I studied the perceptions of the public towards the Zero Emission Vehicle mandate, I conducted several workshops with members of the public. When preparing for them, I found plenty of guidance on WHAT to do: Which methods to use, how to structure a workshop, different ways to elicit information, capture input and seek feedback from participants.
But HOW do we do this? How do you conduct yourself as a facilitator, how to you make participants feel safe and welcome, how do you react to every group and every individual with the same level of interest, curiosity and warmth? After all, how we conduct ourselves as facilitators matters for how willing a participant will be to share their views and speak up. Already in 1954, Hyman et al. (in Seale et al. 2004) noted that interviews benefit from having a good rapport with interviewees, and from consistently applying the procedures and methods to increase homogeneity across the interviews. I like to illustrate this with the following comparison: If you were to do a lab experiment, you’d make sure that your equipment is clean and calibrated to get consistent measurements.
In a research workshop, we researchers are effectively the lab experiment, bringing out and capturing insights from our participants. However, as humans we are not known for our consistency. We may feel energetic one day and tired the next. And, as Ralph and Delbosc (2017) have shown, also transport experts are not free of bias. This risks that we react more enthusiastically to a participant who’s views we share than to one bringing in a different perspective. All of this has potential to influence participant reactions and thereby research outcomes.
To mitigate this risk, I sought facilitation training. It was surprisingly hard to find training on the soft skills needed for participatory research, and I hope to see more work on this in the future. In the meantime, I am sharing two game-changing approaches to facilitation that helped my research.
First and foremost, with the facilitation coach I developed a scenario-based plan for the workshops. This plan covered a range of possible social situations and contained structured approaches for how to handle these situations. For example, what do you do when a participant interrupts you? How do you go about it when two participants have different views?
To give a tangible example: How do you react when a participant drifts into a long monologue? In my research project, the workshop conversations were captured in a mindmap that I drew in real time with the participants. I thus decided that I’d interrupt a monologue as soon as I’d lose sight of how to capture the contribution in the mindmap. Having a few sentences prepared was helpful, such as “Let me briefly interrupt you. I really want to capture your thoughts in the mindmap, could you give me one short sentence to write down?”. Making a participant feel valued also when I interrupted was important to me here.
Secondly, at the start of each workshop I introduced a set of group rules. These included points like “Every contribution is valuable. If we agree with someone, we let them finish their thoughts and then share our own.” and “We will ensure the workshop ends on time.”. These intentions were shared and agreed on at the start of the workshop, with participants having a chance to comment. Through the workshop, the group rules could be used to legitimate facilitator interventions. For example, an existing commitment to keep the workshop to time can be referred back to as a reason to interrupt a monologue.
I didn’t specifically seek to measure the effects of the facilitation training, as at the time I didn’t anticipate just how much of a difference they made. Yet the results were positive. Being prepared and able to facilitate all ten workshops in a consistent and participant-focused manner helped to get a consistent depth of conversation across the groups. Participants commented on enjoying the conversations and felt happy about their contributions and the work of the group. While participants had the option to share anonymous thoughts in writing, none of them did – an indicator that everyone felt safe to speak and share their views to the group.
In the future, I hope to see more conversations around facilitation and the soft skills required for research with participants. I encourage every researcher to think about their own strengths and weaknesses around facilitation, and to prepare for the scenarios and social situations they expect to encounter in their research.
My thanks go to the TGRG for organising several sessions on Creative Methods at the recent RGS conference in Birmingham. Having the space to reflect on and discuss how we do research allows us all to learn from each other – thank you to everyone taking part in these conversations!
Vanessa Ternes, Institute for Transport Studies, University of Leeds
