SHARING RESEARCH PROGRESS AND EXPERIENCES IN MOBILITY TRANSITIONS AND PRACTICES

Franziska Kirschner (Goethe University Frankfurt) & Suzanne Maas (University of Malta), Postgraduate Representatives TGRG

As postgraduate representatives of the Transport Geography Research Group  (TGRG), the highlight of our work is the organisation of sessions for postgraduate students in transport and mobility research at the Royal Geographic Society annual conference. In the beginning of 2020 we were in full swing with planning two sessions for the conference that was due to take place in London in the first week of September. Unfortunately, the global COVID-19 pandemic led to the physical conference being postponed to 2021. Since the sessions we organise are aimed at postgraduate students (at PhD and Master’s level) presenting their current research and progress, we felt waiting for the conference next year would be too long as waiting to present for a year is especially long during the PhD process. Therefore, we decided to organise two online sessions on Thursday 3 September to provide an informal space for the confirmed participants to present and discuss their work.

The morning session, chaired by Franziska Kirschner, focused on ‘mobility transitions’. First up was Fizza Fatima, a Master’s student at TU Darmstadt with her presentation ‘Assessing Urban Mobility Challenges in Karachi, Pakistan, Using the CityStrength Diagnostic’. We learned how Karachi is a megacity without a mass transport system and how the road network needs to provide for all mobility; cars, taxis, motorcycles, auto-rickshaws, etc. A BRT network is planned, but even that would rely on the same contested road space, which is also at risk from flooding. We discussed whether non-motorised modes on the neighbourhood level could help to alleviate some of the pressure on the road network and which transport solutions can connect different land uses and serve disparate neighbourhoods in the city. The second presentation by PhD student Andreas Blitz at Goethe University Frankfurt focused on ‘Cycle streets as an effective measure to promote sustainable transport? Findings of an intervention study’. In his research, he applied the ‘Stage model of self-regulated behaviour change for frequent bicycle use’ to an intervention study of the implementation of a cycle street in Offenbach am Main. His results show the majority of the survey respondents accept the concept of the cycle street, but less than half were actually satisfied with the implementation of it. Regardless, the presence of the cycle street had a positive effect on the stage of change of respondents when compared to a control group: less of them could be characterised as belonging to the pre-decision stage (showing no indications for frequent bicycle use) and more to the pre- and post-action stages (showing positive assessments for cycling or having implemented frequent bicycle use). The third presentation continued on the theme of cycling, with a presentation by PhD candidate Suzanne Maas at the University of Malta, on the topic of ‘Shared bicycle use in three Southern European island cities: A comparative analysis of user experiences’, research funded by the CIVITAS DESTINATIONS project. Her results show the strong relationship between the perception of cycling safety and shared bicycle use in Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Limassol (Cyprus) and Malta. It underlines the importance of separated cycling infrastructure to promote cycling, especially in cities with a low cycling modal share where other road users may not be as accustomed or respectful to cyclists. A quarter of the users in all three cities use their most frequent shared bicycle trip to replace a motorized vehicle trip (previously made by car, taxi, or motorcycle/scooter). In the ensuing discussion, we talked about the perception of cycling as a prerequisite for use, the influence of the pandemic on (pop-up) cycling infrastructure in cities worldwide and the potential for shared bicycles as an individual, but (semi)public transport mode.

The afternoon session, chaired by Suzanne Maas, centred on the theme of ‘mobility practices’. PhD student Sina Selzer of Goethe University Frankfurt presented results from her research on ‘The system of everyday mobility practices of residents of car-reduced housing development’, which is part of the project QuartierMobil funded by the Federal Ministry of Education and Research. We loved the sound of the word ‘carfreeness’ and learned about motivations and practices of residents for not having a car, but also those who do use one. The meanings that her interview subjects gave to their mobility choices are remarkably similar, whether it is a choice for car, bicycle or public transport, and relate to considerations of cost, speed, flexibility and distance. She concludes that motivations for carfreeness “are a combination of the willingness to live car-free and the feasibility”. First-year PhD candidate William Haynes from the University of Sheffield discussed his proposed research on the topic of ‘The railway station as key site of mobility for homeless migrants in Rome’. The (in)visibility and (im)mobility of homeless migrants and their lived experience at the railway station are central to his investigation. How the pandemic might affect his planned research, and how it might have changed or presented new difficulties in these homeless migrants’ lives, are current open questions in his research. Also in the early stages of her PhD, Louise Sträuli from the Tallinn University and Université Libre de Bruxelles, shared her work on ‘Urban Public Transport: tracing the boundaries between public and private space’, research funded by the PUTSPACE project. Her first case study focuses on fare controls and evasion, from which she found that practices of fare evasion arise from different motivations: from necessity, opportunity or dissent. We touched upon some initiatives of fare-free public transport and the pros and cons of such policy proposals. In the discussion, we spoke about different research methods to understand mobility practices, including the possibility of doing ‘travel along’ interviews, to capture the direct experience of interview subjects. We discussed the impacts of gentrification and commercialisation on public space and how interventions, such as automatic turnstiles, cameras and physical measures such as removing benches and adding spikes to urban furniture, are reducing public freedom in transport spaces. And, finally, we discussed the effect of the pandemic on the financing of public transport, on the willingness to used shared mobility modes, as well as on the perception of public space in residential neighbourhoods. The discussions were lively and interesting, thanks to the active contributions of all participating postgraduate students – we really enjoyed the exchange and learned a lot! While appreciating the opportunity to discuss together online, we all hope the conference next year will be able to take place in London as planned, so that we may meet in real life. To strengthen the communication and the discussions among postgraduate students in the field of Transport Geography, we have set up a Linkedin group “Postgraduates in TGRG”, where members can share events and publications and exchange thoughts. We welcome anyone who works or researches topics related to transport and mobility.